Advertisement
question

How reliable is skin fold analysis?

Mike Fantigrassi
Mike Fantigrassi on behalf of National Academy of Sports Medicine
Fitness
answer

If done by a skilled practitioner they can be very accurate, comparable to underwater weighing.  For the best results each site used should be marked and three measurements per site performed.  It would be ideal to use more sites vs. less and have the same person do the test each time. 

In a gym setting three to four sites are common and usually only one measurement per site is performed.  As long as the same person is doing the test each time and they are experienced with using the calipers, than this should provide an accurate measurement of body fat percentage.

National Academy of Sports Medicine
National Academy of Sports Medicine
answer
Calculations have been created to estimate body fat percentage based on skin fold measurements to the same accuracy as hydrostatic weighing.  The calculations and calipers themselves are very accurate.  While there is large room for user error in skin fold measurements, skilled trainers who practice often can obtain up to 98% accuracy.  However, it has been found that skin fold measurements may be less accurate for larger individuals, where it is more difficult to separate muscle and fat by a simple pinch.

Continue Learning about Evaluating & Measuring Fitness

How do I self monitor my exercise?
How do I self monitor my exercise? Self monitoring exercise is being aware of all the impacts of exe...
More Answers
What is the "talk test” and is it accurate to measure exercise intensity?
What is the "talk test” and is it accurate to measure exercise intensity? The talk test is one way t...
More Answers
When should I progress in my exercise program?
When should I progress in my exercise program? Progression is inevitable if you are exercising corre...
More Answers
What should my heart rate be during cardio exercise?
What should my heart rate be during cardio exercise? Your heart rate (and exercise intensity) during...
More Answers

Important: This content reflects information from various individuals and organizations and may offer alternative or opposing points of view. It should not be used for medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. As always, you should consult with your healthcare provider about your specific health needs.