Why is my A1C high when my blood sugar levels are in my target range?

William Lee Dubois

I want you to picture a freshly fried doughnut hole, just out of the deep fryer. Steam wafts from its surface. Still gleaming wet with oil, it’s sent spinning across a tray of powdered sugar. As it tumbles, sugar sticks to the wet oil, coating it, covering it as it rolls and bounces along.

Well, the same thing happens to your red blood cells. As they tumble and spin and roll through your blood vessels, sugar molecules stick to their skins. Or another way to think of it is to picture a windshield of a truck after driving through a swarm of mosquitoes. Splat-Splat-Splat-Splat-Splat! (OK, I just threw that in so you wouldn’t log off and drive straight to Dunkin Doughnuts.)

So an A1C test is a measure of how much of the skins of your red blood cells are splattered with sugar, which in turn gives us a picture of the blood sugar environment in which the cells lived, which in turn gives us a notion of your average blood sugar over the last several months.

So the A1C test looks at average blood sugar, while your fingersticks look at moments in time. The most common cause of a difference between A1C and fingersticks is that the fingersticks are not frequent enough, or are not at the right times to catch the elevated blood sugars that are jacking your A1C to higher levels.

For instance, if you are only testing in the morning, you are missing possible elevations after meals or overnight while you are sleeping. The A1C test is not perfect. For instance, if your sugar was ranging scary low to scary high you might get a number that looked pretty good. That said, most “false reads” are good looking numbers that mask troublesome variability. Additionally, if you are anemic, you can also get a false low, as your blood cells don’t last as long as typical.

But if your A1C is high, there are some high blood sugars lurking somewhere. And that is exactly why we do both fingerstick testing a A1Cs. They serve as checks and balances against each other.

Stacy Wiegman, PharmD
Pharmacy Specialist

Results of an A1C test and a blood glucose check don't always match up. The A1C test measures your average blood sugar levels over a 120-day period (the lifespan of a red blood cell). But a blood glucose check measures your blood sugar at a single moment. If your blood sugar levels were high last week, and you adjusted your diabetes treatment plan so that your blood sugar returned to normal, the A1C result may still be high, because it includes the high blood sugar levels from the previous week.

The A1C test measures the percentage of glycated hemoglobin in your blood. Glycated hemoglobin is created when molecules of hemoglobin (the oxygen-carrying protein in your blood) attach to molecules of glucose (the sugar in your blood). The more sugar you have in your blood, the higher your percentage of glycated hemoglobin.

Your A1C may be high, above 7 percent, when your blood sugar levels are in your target range because you have recently begun properly managing your diabetes. Likewise, if you have out of range blood glucose checks but your A1C is 7 percent or below, it may be that for the past two months you’ve managed your diabetes well, but as of recently you haven’t been able to do so.

The A1C test tells the average plasma glucose exposure over the life of a red blood cell, which is three months, or how much blood sugar is attached to your red blood cells. Your A1C is increased by hyperglycemic episodes. A1C and daily blood sugar checks can be used to get a better understanding of your blood glucose management. 

Your blood glucose levels are probably based on your premeal blood glucose levels. While this usually works well, it does not take into account the level of your blood glucose after you eat. It may be that your blood glucose is rising unexpectedly after your meal because you are either not taking enough insulin or not taking insulin far enough ahead of eating your meal. To see if this is the reason that your A1C is high, measure your blood glucose 2 hours after breakfast, lunch, and dinner for several days (in addition to your premeal blood glucose levels). Blood sugar that is more than 200 mg/dl 2 hours after a meal is too high. In addition, your blood glucose may be high throughout the night, when you are asleep. To find out, wake yourself up at 4:00 a.m. several times during the week to check your blood glucose. At 4:00 a.m., blood glucose that is higher than 150 mg/dl is too high. Continue to check your blood glucose 2 hours after meals and in the middle of the night once a month to be certain that you are not having unexpected high blood glucose levels at these times.


Continue Learning about Diabetes

Diabetes-Friendly Foods for Your Eyes
Diabetes-Friendly Foods for Your Eyes
Diabetes is a condition that prevents your body from producing or responding to the insulin it needs to bring sugar from the blood stream to cells, wh...
Read More
Are continuous glucose monitors (CGMs) covered by Medicare?
Taking Control Of Your Diabetes (TCOYD)Taking Control Of Your Diabetes (TCOYD)
Most people with diabetes are aware of the benefits of continuous glucose monitoring (CGM). A CGM he...
More Answers
9 Keys to Preventing and Treating Diabetic Foot Issues
9 Keys to Preventing and Treating Diabetic Foot Issues9 Keys to Preventing and Treating Diabetic Foot Issues9 Keys to Preventing and Treating Diabetic Foot Issues9 Keys to Preventing and Treating Diabetic Foot Issues
Being proactive can help keep your feet healthy.
Start Slideshow
If I Lose Weight, Can I Stop Taking My Diabetes Medications?
If I Lose Weight, Can I Stop Taking My Diabetes Medications?

Important: This content reflects information from various individuals and organizations and may offer alternative or opposing points of view. It should not be used for medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. As always, you should consult with your healthcare provider about your specific health needs.