A Last-Minute Guide to Shopping for Medicare

A Last-Minute Guide to Shopping for Medicare

If you're down to the wire, here's what you need to know.

Medicare’s annual open enrollment period is about to come to a close. December 7 is your final chance to change from one Medicare Advantage or prescription drug plan to another. If you’re currently enrolled in Original Medicare, you can also switch to a private Medicare Advantage plan, or drop existing Medicare Advantage coverage to return to Original Medicare.

If you’re like a lot of people, you’ve waited until the very last minute to shop your options.

“We do see a lot of folks rushing at the end,” says Joe Baker, president of the Medicare Rights Center.

There are a number of reasons for that, Baker says: inertia, fear or feeling overwhelmed with too much choice. “It’s not the kind of shopping people like to do, and it’s confusing,” he says. 

That’s why many experts suggest you seek help, particularly as the time left to make a choice dwindles.

“When it's the last few days of annual enrollment and down to the wire, that's when beneficiaries can make costly mistakes rushing to pick a plan without help and guidance,” says Michael Tadlock, vice president of product management at eHealth, which runs

Experts say Medicare beneficiaries have lots of questions about how to find the right plan. Here, they answer some of the most common questions asked during Medicare annual enrollment.

If I’m happy with my coverage, do I really have to do anything? 
“The simple answer is yes,” says Nicole Durtiz, vice president of health education and outreach with AARP.  

Here’s why: Although you’re not required to take any action to hold onto your current plan for 2015 (as long as it’s still being offered next year), doing so without shopping your options could cost you. Changes that occur in Medicare Advantage and prescription drug plans each year can alter your coverage in ways that may no longer work for you or your wallet. 

You may be happy with your coverage this year and assume it will be identical in 2016, Durtiz says, “but that’s often not the case.”

What people tend not to realize until it’s too late is that their doctor is no longer covered by their plan, or that the medications they take have been moved to a different, higher cost drug tier, meaning higher out-of-pocket costs at the pharmacy.  

“They wouldn’t know that until too late if they haven’t done that investigation,” Durtiz says.

Her advice: “Spend a little bit of time making sure your needs haven’t changed and the insurance company hasn’t made a business decision that impacts your coverage.”

What’s the best plan for me?
“This is the most common question we get,” Baker says.

Unfortunately, there’s no one right answer. “We can’t tell people which plan is the best of the best for them. It’s an individualized decision,” he says.

However, there are some rules of thumb to follow that can help you get at the right choice.

In many markets, you may have 30 or more plans from which to choose, so start by limiting your options to avoid feeling overwhelmed. You can do that by using the Medicare Star system which rates plans on a scale of one to five stars, with five being the best, based on the agency's assessment of medical services and customer satisfaction. Filter out lower-rated plans and stick with just those that have received four and five stars.

“That may be a way to cut the list in half,” Baker says. 

He also suggests having a conversation with your doctors or pharmacist. “They may steer you away from plans that don’t do a good job covering the stuff you need,” he says.  

Durtiz suggests people focus on “the four Cs” to making shopping easier: cost, coverage, convenience and customer service. 

First up is cost. Look beyond a plan’s monthly premium and evaluate deductibles and other costs such as copayments and coinsurance you’ll be required to pay when you go for care. 

Also evaluate the type of coverage you’ll gain with each plan. For example, check that your doctor and other providers participate. Make sure your medications are covered and check for any rules you’ll have to follow to get help paying for them. For example, will you be required to try a less expensive generic medication before gaining approval for the pricier brand-name drug your doctor prescribed? Does the plan impose medication quantity limits or prior approval in order for your medications to be covered? All this can impact your access to care and your costs. 

Convenience is an important consideration as well, Durtiz says. “If you pick a plan and the only pharmacy is two subway stops and a bus ride away or if the only hospital is a county away, that’s an issue,” Durtiz says. Make sure the providers you need to use are conveniently located to your home. 

Finally, whether you shop online or with the help of an expert, check those star ratings to get a sense of how plans do on customer service. “See how well they interact with clients, handle disputes and how quickly they answered the phone,” Durtiz says. 

How can I find out if Medicare covers the drug or treatment I need? 
There are many reputable sources where you can get free information to assist you in making your plan selection.  

You can log onto or call 1-800-Medicare to ask service representatives about the specific care you need.  

The Medicare Rights Center offers an online interactive tool where you can ask and receive answers to your questions at 

AARP also has a Medicare Questions and Answers Tool available both in English and Spanish.  

And private sites such as provide online question and answer tools. There, you can also connect with insurance agents specializing in Medicare Advantage and prescription drug plans for free assistance with your selection process.  

“The other way of doing it is by asking your providers,” Baker says. “They deal with these plans for a lot of different people.”   

Often, your doctor’s office can tell you which plans do a better job covering the particular drugs or treatments you need.  

Where do I go for help signing up?
To review your plan options you can log onto Medicare plan finder at, or call (800) MEDICARE.

There are also free, personalized counseling services available around the country through State Health Insurance Assistance Programs. To find help near you log onto or call (800) 677-1116.

And can connect you with licensed insurance agents able to help you find and sign up for a plan.

“The decision seniors make in the last few days of Annual Enrollment will impact their finances and possibly their health for the next full year. Getting it right is imperative,” says Tadlock of eHealth.

Baker agrees, but says people are often fearful of the process or of making the wrong choice. They become frozen and do nothing, which is perhaps the biggest mistake of all.

“It is a hard decision but not so momentous that you won’t be able to do it.”

Related: See all Medicare articles

This content originally appeared on U.S. News & World Report.

Medically reviewed in March 2020.

5 Ways Medicare Has Changed in 50 Years
5 Ways Medicare Has Changed in 50 Years
It has been 50 years since President Lyndon Johnson signed a health insurance program for older Americans into law on July 30, 1965. Medicare continue...
Read More
When was Medicare developed?
Dr. Michael Roizen, MDDr. Michael Roizen, MD
Medicare was officially signed into law on July 30, 1965, but Harry Truman started throwing around t...
More Answers
Can I get Medicare before age 65?
Usually you must wait until you reach 65 to get Medicare. But there are some exceptions. You can bec...
More Answers
What Type of Policy Changes Is AARP Advocating?
What Type of Policy Changes Is AARP Advocating?