How can I appeal an insurance coverage denial?

Dr. Mehmet Oz, MD
Cardiology (Cardiovascular Disease)
You may be able to get the health insurer to change their decision without launching a formal appeal. But if those efforts don't work, follow this strategy when it's time to get serious.
  1. Follow all the rules—thoroughly. Ask the insurer and your human resources department at work to send you the complete rules for filing an appeal, and follow those rules to the "T." The insurance company is hoping you'll flub something or send in incomplete paperwork so they can toss your appeal without any sweat. Do you need to get a second opinion? Which bills, test results, or other paperwork do you need to include in your appeal application? Be exacting. Don't let the health insurer bounce your appeal on a technicality. Be especially vigilant about deadlines.
  2. Get some outside info. For advice to help you craft your appeal, see the Web site at If you're appealing a Medicare denial, tap the knowledge from the Medicare Rights Center at or (888) 466-9050.
  3. Bombard them with facts. You won't get anywhere with passionate pleas. You need lab data, national trend info, physician letters, and other hard records to show the insurer why it has no basis to deny your claim. Ask your doctor to send a letter saying why you need the treatment; it'll pack more punch coming from him or her.
  4. Seek the MD. Your goal is to get your case to the insurer's medical director or staff doctor. A doctor will usually look at your situation with more sympathetic eyes and give more clout to good patient care versus following the standard policies. Keep pushing until you get that physician involved.
  5. Use smart timing. When you get to that doctor, you want to speak to him or her on a Monday morning or a Friday afternoon, when this person is likely in the best mood.You can't reach the doctor? Unacceptable! Tell the insurer that you're going to bring the matter to the state department of insurance or the attorney general. Don't use this threat too soon; it'll cost you goodwill (which still influences some folks on this good earth, believe it or not), so save it as a last resort.
  6. Rat 'em out. No satisfaction, even after the plan's doctor gets involved? If you're not ready to say uncle yet, take your appeal to the state department of insurance. I'm pulling for you.
YOU: The Smart Patient: An Insider's Handbook for Getting the Best Treatment

More About this Book

YOU: The Smart Patient: An Insider's Handbook for Getting the Best Treatment

Everyone needs to become a smart patient. In fact, in the worst cases, your life may even depend on it. Number one bestselling authors and doctors Michael Roizen and Mehmet Oz have written this...

Continue Learning about Health Insurance

Healthcare Generosity has Overwhelming Benefits for You and Society
Healthcare Generosity has Overwhelming Benefits for You and Society
In tough times, lots of folks think when it comes to healthcare, tightening the purse strings, letting folks fend for themselves and advocating tough ...
Read More
Why did I get a bill from a medical facility if I have health insurance?
Having health insurance does not mean you will never receive a bill from a medical facility. There c...
More Answers
What should I know about my health insurance before going to the ER?
 Dr. Kathleen Handal, MD Dr. Kathleen Handal, MD
Once an emergency brings you to the ER, the details of your insurance coverage will be secondary...
More Answers
What short-term needs should I consider when reviewing my life insurance?
Philip Lisagor, MDPhilip Lisagor, MD
When reviewing your short-term life insurance coverage needs, you should consider: What assets w...
More Answers

Important: This content reflects information from various individuals and organizations and may offer alternative or opposing points of view. It should not be used for medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. As always, you should consult with your healthcare provider about your specific health needs.