Is Your BMI a Lie?

Is Your BMI a Lie?

Study: “Obese” Doesn’t Always Mean “Unhealthy”

Body mass index (BMI), a simple ratio of height and weight, has become a shorthand way for doctors and insurance companies to determine if someone is healthy. And, according to the Centers for Disease Control, about one-third of Americans are considered obese by this measure. The problem? A 2016 study published in the International Journal of Obesity found that millions of people in the “obese” range are actually healthy in terms of blood pressure, cholesterol, blood sugar and similar tests, while many with “normal” BMIs are worse off.

But your BMI could be used to discriminate against you. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission is proposing to allow employers to penalize people based on their BMI results, meaning healthy people may be overcharged for insurance because their BMI is too high.

So, is your BMI a lie? We talked to Matthew Brengman, MD, FACS, a bariatric surgeon at Parham Doctors' Hospital in Virginia to uncover the truth.

What is your opinion of the study? Is BMI accurate?
The study is a little exaggerated, honestly. It accentuates a point that a lot of people have made over the years: BMI is not everything because it’s only as good as your height and your weight. We also know that BMI is not particularly accurate when height and weight are self-reported. And while there is a role for BMI, it’s just not a great indicator for insurance companies to charge people more if they have a higher BMI.

Bottom line: BMI by itself shouldn’t be making medical decisions, and guess what, we don’t.

Is body composition a better measure of overall health?
It can be better, but it’s very difficult to do, and body composition is not something that we have accessibility to everywhere. So yes, the percentage of body fat in combination with overall weight is a better than weight or BMI alone in predicting morbidity or likelihood to develop disease.

What could mislabeling a person as obese do to their overall health? 
We shouldn’t ignore BMI, but we also shouldn’t overestimate its value. The misconception is that everyone with BMI of 30 is ill at that moment, and that is not true. This study is just a snapshot in time, but weight has a cumulative effect on health over a period time. For example, a 20 year old with a BMI of 30 is much less likely to be sick compared to a 50 year old with the same BMI over the past 30 years.

The study author said this should be the final nail in the coffin for BMI. Will it be?
I think that is a pipe dream because we do not have the resources for better testing. If the authors are suggesting that we need to do the battery of tests on every single patient like they did in the study, I would like to see where that money came from. BMI does have value, we just shouldn’t make insurance decisions based on it.

People are going to still measure BMI. In my field, weight loss surgery, we have been using BMI as one of the major indicators for surgery since 1991, based on guidelines from the National Institutes of Health, and they actually reconvened a few years ago, and still included BMI as one of the measures for weight loss surgery, so there are no nails I don’t think.

See More from Dr. Brengman:

Medically reviewed in February 2020.

Weighty Matters: How Excess Weight Is Ruining Your Future—and Your Kids Future Too
Weighty Matters: How Excess Weight Is Ruining Your Future—and Your Kids Future Too
One more time we’re weighing in on the goodness of maintaining a healthy weight. And we have some intriguing new insights into weighty matters—and inn...
Read More
How do I know if I am apple-shaped or pear-shaped?
Debra Fulghum Bruce PhDDebra Fulghum Bruce PhD
Here’s a simple formula to tell if you are an apple or pear: Break out your measuring tape, measure ...
More Answers
How do you interpret body mass index (BMI) for adults?
Barbara Ficarra, RNBarbara Ficarra, RN
BMI is interpreted using standard weight status categories for adults 20 years old and older.  BM...
More Answers
What Does the Waist to Hip Ratio Determine?
What Does the Waist to Hip Ratio Determine?