See All Psychotherapists in Merrick, NY
Otylia McQuay, LCSW

Otylia McQuay, LCSW

Age 43 Psychotherapy F
(31) 31 reviews
Accepting New Patients


Otylia McQuay, LCSW is a Psychotherapist in Merrick, NY. Otylia McQuay studied at Columbia University|Columbia University School of Social Work. They currently practice at Otylia Tilly McQuay, LCSW-R and are affiliated with Mount Sinai Hospital. Otylia McQuay accepts multiple insurance plans.


  • Department of Psychiatry at Federal Bureau of Prisons, Metropolitan Detention Center DBT project|New York Presbyterian Hospital, Payne Whitney Clinic|NYP Hospital Employee Assistance Program Counseling Center|NYP Hospital Weill Cornell Medical Center, Internship Hospital — 2010
  • Columbia University|Columbia University School of Social Work, Medical School — 2010

Insurance Accepted

  • Aetna
  • Cigna
  • Fidelis Care
  • Health First Health Plans
  • Healthfirst
  • MagnaCare
  • Oxford Health Plans

* Please verify this information when scheduling an appointment.



Patient Satisfaction

Likelihood to recommend Otylia McQuay
Based on 31 Reviews
5 Stars
4 Stars
3 Stars
2 Stars
1 Star

Leave a review

How likely are you to recommend Otylia McQuay?

(Select your rating)
Dec 14, 2022
I highly recommend Tilly, especially if you struggle with family issues and have had trauma in your life. Prior to seeing her, I was never properly diagnosed, and kept feeling like therapy would never help. Now that I know that I suffer from Complex PTSD, it truly changed my life. Tilly is a great listener and she really cares. A+!!
MP — Dec 14, 2022
See more reviews on Healthgrades
Photo: Otylia McQuay, LCSW
How would you rate your experience with Otylia McQuay, LCSW?
  • Likelihood of recommending Otylia McQuay to family and friends

Otylia McQuay's Office & Staff

  • Ease of scheduling urgent appointments
  • Office environment, cleanliness, comfort, etc.
  • Staff friendliness and courteousness
  • Total wait time (waiting & exam rooms)

Experience with Otylia McQuay

  • Level of trust in provider's decisions
  • How well provider explains medical condition(s)
  • How well provider listens and answers questions
  • Spends appropriate amount of time with patients

Tell Us About Yourself

  • Your gender:
  • Your age group:
  • Number of office visits you've had in the last 2 years:

Finish Here

  • How would you like to confirm your survey information?
    Standard text messaging and data rates may apply.
Thank you for sharing your feedback about Otylia McQuay, LCSW.
Claim Your Profile
Are you Otylia McQuay, LCSW?
Claim and manage your free profile or contact our support team.

Frequently Asked Questions

Find contact information here to make an appointment.

A list of accepted insurance providers is available on the Sharecare insurance check. It is always a good idea to verify your insurance when making an appointment.

New patients are generally accepted by Otylia McQuay, LCSW. To arrange an appointment, call the number on Otylia McQuay's profile.

Otylia McQuay, LCSW is affiliated with Mount Sinai Hospital.

Hospital Affiliations

  • Mount Sinai Hospital


  1. Otylia Tilly McQuay, LCSW-R

    1. 1
      Private Office
      124 Merrick Ave, Merrick, NY 11566 (516) 415-2071