Pfizer and Moderna COVID-19 Vaccines Are 90 Percent Effective in ‘Real-World’ Conditions, CDC Says

Scientists will continue to monitor how well and safely these vaccines work outside of tightly controlled trials.

woman getting vaccinated

Medically reviewed in April 2021

Updated on March 31, 2021

Additional reporting by Veronica Hackethal, MD.

Under real-world conditions, the mRNA COVID-19 vaccines developed by Pfizer and Moderna are 90 percent effective in preventing the disease, according to data released on March 29 by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).

The CDC study followed 3,950 health care workers, first responders and other frontline employees in eight locations across the United States as the initial doses of the COVID-19 vaccines were rolled out in December 2020.

The participants were tested on a weekly basis for COVID-19—even if they didn’t have any symptoms of the infection.

The study found that at least 14 days after the first dose, the vaccines were 80 percent effective. And at least two weeks after the second dose, they were 90 percent effective.

Why have the numbers changed?
Pfizer announced the first set of complete results from their ongoing coronavirus vaccine trial in November 2020. The results suggested their two-dose mRNA vaccine, which was developed in partnership with BioNTech, is 95 percent effective against COVID-19, starting 28 days after the first dose.

The late-stage clinical trial results were based on an evaluation of 170 confirmed cases of COVID-19 with 162 observed in the placebo group compared to 8 in the vaccine group.

Just days later, Moderna released its Phase 3 trial results, which found that its mRNA vaccine is 94.1 percent effective against COVID-19.

For Moderna's Phase 3 trial, about 15,000 volunteers were given a placebo, or a shot of saline. Another roughly 15,000 volunteers received the experimental vaccine.

In short, the proportion of symptomatic coronavirus cases fell by 95 percent among those who received the Pfizer vaccine compared to the placebo group. For the Moderna vaccine, the proportion of new, symptomatic COVID-19 cases was decreased by 94.1 percent for vaccinated people compared to the placebo group.

So, what’s the difference between these Phase 3 results and the real-world data?

Trial efficacy vs. real-world effectiveness
Researchers define efficacy as how well a new medical treatment performs under ideal or controlled conditions, like a clinical trial. It’s a rate that’s calculated using a formula. In human trials, it’s the percent reduction in new, symptomatic COVID-19 cases among vaccinated people, compared to people who got the placebo.

“These numbers only refer to the percent reduction in COVID cases between placebo and vaccinated. They do not translate into your chances of getting COVID if you’ve been vaccinated,” explains Namandje Bumpus, PhD, professor of pharmacology and molecular sciences at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine. “They really refer to the clinical trial specifically, not the real world.”

On the other hand, the effectiveness of a new medical treatment describes how well it actually performs in the real world.

Why the CDC study is important
The CDC study included a total of 2,961 people who received at least one shot (including five people who got the Johnson & Johnson vaccine) and 989 unvaccinated people. Overall, researched confirmed a total of 205 cases of COVID-19. Of these, 161 involved unvaccinated people, eight infections were reported in partially immunized people and three fully vaccinated people were diagnosed with the infection. The researchers noted that 33 cases were excluded from the findings because their immune status couldn’t be verified.

Among the confirmed COVID-19 cases, only two people were hospitalized, and no deaths were reported.

Overall, these real-world results are not very different from the clinical trials. But this data is needed to show how well and safely these vaccines work outside of tightly controlled conditions.

As more people are vaccinated, this data will continue to be collected, providing a better idea of how well these vaccines protect people over time.

Article sources open article sources

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. “Interim Estimates of Vaccine Effectiveness of BNT162b2 and mRNA-1273 COVID-19 Vaccines in Preventing SARS-CoV-2 Infection Among Health Care Personnel, First Responders, and Other Essential and Frontline Workers — Eight U.S. Locations, December 2020–March 2021.” Mar 29, 2021.
Pfizer. “PFIZER AND BIONTECH CONCLUDE PHASE 3 STUDY OF COVID-19 VACCINE CANDIDATE, MEETING ALL PRIMARY EFFICACY ENDPOINTS.” Nov 18, 2020.
U.S. Food and Drug Administration. “Vaccines and Related Biological Products Advisory Committee Meeting; FDA Briefing Document: Moderna COVID-19 Vaccine.” Dec 17, 2020.
Singal AG, Higgins PD, Waljee AK. “A primer on effectiveness and efficacy trials.” Clin Transl Gastroenterol. 2014;5(1):e45.

More On

CDC Urges Those Who Are Pregnant to Get a COVID Vaccine

article

CDC Urges Those Who Are Pregnant to Get a COVID Vaccine
Evidence of the benefits of vaccination during pregnancy outweighs any known or potential risks.
Pfizer and BioNTech Say Their COVID Vaccine is Safe for Younger Kids

article

Pfizer and BioNTech Say Their COVID Vaccine is Safe for Younger Kids
Children between 5 and 11-years old to get a lower dose than teens and adults and it may be authorized by late October.
What Is Long COVID Brain Fog—And Can It Be Cleared?

article

What Is Long COVID Brain Fog—And Can It Be Cleared?
Overall, 7.5 percent of people have lingering symptoms, such as brain fog, weeks, months, or even years after recovering from COVID. Get the latest.
CDC Recommends Omicron Boosters For Kids as Young as 6 Months Old

article

CDC Recommends Omicron Boosters For Kids as Young as 6 Months Old
Learn why the booster was updated and who is eligible to get the shot.
Pfizer-BioNTech COVID Vaccine Wins Full FDA Approval

article

Pfizer-BioNTech COVID Vaccine Wins Full FDA Approval
The approval may encourage more people to get immunized and prompt organizations to mandate vaccination.