Question

Weight Loss Diets

Is the Paleo diet safe and effective?

A Answers (2)

  • ARobert Davis, PhD, Health Education, answered
    The so-called Caveman Diet, also known as the Paleo Diet, is based on what people are presumed to have eaten before the emergence of agriculture 10,000 years ago.

    The diet includes foods our ancestors could have hunted or gathered, such as lean meat, fish, eggs, vegetables, fruits and nuts. It prohibits things not available to them, such as dairy products, grains, salt and sugar.

    The rationale is that human beings aren't genetically designed to eat much of what we put into our bodies today. Nature intended us to follow a prehistoric diet, the theory goes, and our failure to do so has led to the epidemics of obesity, heart disease, diabetes and other chronic conditions.

    As evidence, proponents cite the experiences of societies that have stuck closely to this dietary ideal. One is the tropical island of Kitava, part of Papua New Guinea, where studies show that modern maladies are rare. However, it's impossible to know for certain whether this is due to the Kitavans' diet or some other aspect of their lifestyle.

    Several small, short-term studies have measured the effects of a Caveman Diet in Western populations. In one, nine overweight subjects who were put on the diet for 10 days experienced improvements in blood pressure, cholesterol, and glucose tolerance (a measure of how well the body handles sugar). In others involving people with diabetes or prediabetes, a Caveman Diet resulted in better glucose tolerance than a Mediterranean diet and more favorable readings for blood pressure, good cholesterol, and weight than a standard diabetes diet.

    Though the research is too preliminary to permit any firm conclusions, it does appear that the diet's embrace of fruits, veggies and nuts, along with its avoidance of sweets, refined grains and junk food, makes it healthful overall. But there's little evidence that shunning whole grains, beans or dairy is necessary for optimal health.

    Nor is there proof that eating lots of meat, as many of the diet's adherents do, is beneficial, and it could be harmful. The wild beasts that cavemen killed and consumed are a far cry from what we get at the supermarket -- even if it's organic, free-range and grass-fed.

    In truth, we can't be sure what cavemen ate, which is a problem with the whole concept. Based on what anthropologists do know, prehistoric diets varied widely depending on where people lived and what was available to them.

    Until there's stronger evidence, you may be better off leaving this diet in the history books.
    Helpful? 1 person found this helpful.
  • AJennifer L. McDaniel, Nutrition & Dietetics, answered on behalf of Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics

    The Paleo diet is a high-protein, low-carbohydrate way of eating. Many dieters have been successful in weight-loss when reducing carbohydrates in their diet, while maintaining a high level of protein. A recent study in Nutrition & Metabolism found that Paleo dieters felt satisfied in terms of appetite, and also had lower levels of circulating leptin, a hormone that regulates appetite and fat storage. 

    Concerns with the Paleo diet are similar to that of any restrictive diet. Limiting food groups such as dairy, grains and beans (which are excluded on the Paleo) limits potentially vital nutrients. Nutrients such as calcium, potassium, some B vitamins and fiber may be inadequate. Diets high in protein, yet low in calcium may put an individual at risk for bone mineral losses. 

    Other drawbacks of the Paleo diet are the logistics of basing a meal plan on the limited foods, cost (esp. if eating only organic and grass-fed foods), and the ability to follow the plan when eating away from home. 

    Overall, this diet can be safe and effective if the meal plan is filled with a variety of Paleo foods and is not overly restrictive in its calories.

    Helpful? 1 person found this helpful.
Did You See?  Close
What foods are included on a Paleo plate?