Advertisement
question

Do I need surgery if a HIDA scan showed my gallbladder functioning at 8%?

Anthony L. Komaroff, MD
Anthony L. Komaroff, MD
Internal Medicine
answer
I assume your doctor sent you for the HIDA scan because your abdominal pain raised her suspicion of gallstones, yet none were found on an ultrasound of your abdomen. In this case, the health of the gallbladder is assessed by measuring its ability to contract and squeeze out bile.

Your HIDA scan measured the "ejection fraction" of your gallbladder. Once the gallbladder is filled with HIDA (a radioactive substance), the hormone cholecystokinin is injected into a vein. The cholecystokinin stimulates the gallbladder into emptying out the HIDA. Healthy gallbladders squeeze out at least 35% of the HIDA. Your HIDA test was abnormal because only 8% of the HIDA left your gallbladder.

The decision to proceed with gallbladder surgery to relieve your pain should hinge on more than a single test.

Most important is the impression of your doctor after she considers your symptoms and performs a physical exam.

Pain typical of so-called "biliary colic" is felt just below the right rib cage. It comes shortly after eating and may spread to the right shoulder and back. Nausea and sweating sometimes join the pain. The area will feel tender when pressed at the time of an attack.

Biliary colic is most often related to gallstones that get stuck in the bile duct. Sometimes people experience episodes of biliary colic but don't have gallstones. The HIDA scan can be abnormal, similar to your result.

If you don't have gallstones, surgery may not relieve your symptoms. The likelihood that surgery will give long-term relief from symptoms of "acalculous" (meaning without stones) biliary pain is between 65% and 80%.

Acalculous biliary pain can actually get better on its own. The reasons aren't clear. As many as 50% of patients become pain-free without having an operation. So it is really a decision to be made with your doctor, who can also assess your overall risk for surgery.

Continue Learning about Digestive Health

6 Reasons You May See Blood in Your Poop
6 Reasons You May See Blood in Your Poop
Seeing drops of red in your stool is scary, especially when you don’t know why. Often, the cause is benign—red food like beets or cake frosting can ch...
Read More
Is It Gas or Irritable Bowel Syndrome?
Is It Gas or Irritable Bowel Syndrome?
Sometimes, gas is the result of your menstrual cycle or your last meal. Other times, gas plus pain and changes in your bowel movements can signal a co...
Read More
Common Questions about Bloating and Gas
Common Questions about Bloating and Gas
I hear concerns about gas and bloating all the time from patients. What may freak you out is that the average adult produces about one to three pints ...
Read More
5 Things That Happen to Your Body When You Stop Eating Meat
5 Things That Happen to Your Body When You Stop Eating Meat
You may have heard the about the health benefits of eating less meat. People who follow plant-based diets low in processed foods and sugar tend to hav...
Read More

Important: This content reflects information from various individuals and organizations and may offer alternative or opposing points of view. It should not be used for medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. As always, you should consult with your healthcare provider about your specific health needs.